|
Attention Irish Infidels
Will probably be visiting Ireland sometime soon. Haven't booked anything yet but current possible plan is:
Monday 24 July: Fly from London to Dublin. Probably wouldn't spend all the time in Dublin: take either day trips or overnight trips to somewhere else. So, questions:
What I'm Reading Plot's handled OK, though the ending is a little anticlimactic. Character development is reasonable, though the love story is bit too easy. Liked it enough to order a couple more books by the author. I'd read some of his short stories in Interzone a while back, but hadn't really got into any of his novels before.
Politics I mean: any political philosophy with more than a few thousand believers tends to have had a certain amount of intellectual work put into it, and a certain amount of consistency. In my case, even though I strongly disagree with many of them, I can look at their arguments and I usually find that it's their premises that I disagree with, not their logic. It seems far more frequent that their assumptions are wrong than that they're using logical fallacies. (Note that this doesn't apply to particular individuals. Individuals can adhere to political beliefs for entirely irrational or illogical reasons, but if it's a moderately widely-held belief there are always other individuals who have created an intelligible framework to surround it). Now, in many cases, I think these frameworks are rationalized, rather than strictly rational. People unconsciously choose to make certain assumptions in order that they can be led to beliefs that they want to hold. Arguments like these seem to me to be made almost entirely to justify a belief that's felt at a gut level. But even so, while it's rationalized, it's still not irrational. Premises, arguments and conclusions exist, even if I don't find them persuasive. And there's absolutely no way I can prove my own gut suspicion that the premises are chosen to fit the conclusion, rather than the other way around. So no, I don't find it baffling at all that other people have very different political beliefs to me.
|